Step 1 — Define the concept: what copyright actually covers
Copyright sounds like it should settle this question. An athlete creates a move, so the athlete owns it. In practice, it does not work like that. Copyright protects a work: a longer, original routine that is fixed, meaning recorded on video or written down in notation. It does not protect a single step, however famous that step becomes.
The US Copyright Office states this directly. Its Circular 52 explains that it cannot register “short dance routines consisting of only a few movements or steps … even if a routine is novel or distinctive,” and it names one example explicitly:
“A celebratory end zone dance move or athletic victory gesture.”— US Copyright Office, Circular 52 (rev. 10/2022)
The distinction matters because it produces two opposite results for the same athlete. A five-minute choreographed routine, filmed and registered, can be a protected work. A two-second shiver after a goal cannot. The protection does not follow the fame. It follows the paperwork.
Step 2 — Test it against the evidence: what happened when people sued
When Fortnite sold emotes copying viral dances, the creators sued — and lost. Alfonso Ribeiro’s “Carlton” dance, the Backpack Kid’s Floss, and 2 Milly’s Milly Rock were all filed in December 2018, and all were dropped in 2019. The Copyright Office refused to register Ribeiro’s routine on 22 January 2019, describing it as a “simple routine” of three dance steps.
A second rule compounded the problem. Under Fourth Estate Public Benefit Corp. v. Wall-Street.com (2019), a plaintiff cannot file a US copyright lawsuit until the Copyright Office has actually registered the work. That ruling is what forced the 2019 Fortnite plaintiffs to withdraw. The sequence is therefore not a detail: register first, sue second. Most of the plaintiffs had it backwards.
Step 3 — Isolate the exception: the one who registered first
Choreographer Kyle Hanagami was the exception, and his case settled. Hanagami owned a registered five-minute routine, created for Charlie Puth’s “How Long” video in 2017, and Epic had copied a four-count portion of it. A district court first dismissed his claim as mere “poses.” On 1 November 2023, however, the Ninth Circuit reversed in Hanagami v. Epic Games: choreography works like music — individual notes are unprotectable on their own, but the selection and arrangement of them can be. The case was remanded, then settled on 12 February 2024, on undisclosed terms.
The critical point is not that Hanagami’s work was more famous. It is that he had completed the administrative step first: a long, fixed, registered work, in place before anyone copied it. In this system, preparation is not a formality. It is the difference between a claim and a headline.
Step 4 — Apply the route that works: trademark the picture
That is why today’s stars file trademarks, not copyrights. A trademark protects a sign that tells consumers where goods come from: a word like CR7, a stylised silhouette like Nike’s Jumpman — registered in the US in 1989, and owned by Nike, not by Jordan — a figurative image of a pose, or, in the UK and EU, a short video clip known as a motion mark.
ENSafrica summarises the limit precisely: trademark law “does not protect a physical movement per se. What it protects is the visual depiction of that movement … when it functions as a badge of commercial origin” — and it does “not prevent fans or rival players from mimicking a gesture. The protection is commercial, not performative.”
Concretely, a trademark can stop a brand from putting your pose on a T-shirt. It cannot stop a kid in the stands, or a rival on the pitch, from doing it. Knowing exactly where that line sits — between the commercial and the performative — is the whole analysis.